Hearney 6:02 Tue Aug 18
Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
|
Not good news!!
Randolf in goal for the next 3 games *GULPS*
|
|
|
Replies - Newest Posts First ( Show In Chronological Order)
Lily Hammer
4:31 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
OK Fifth, but I still think Carlton endangered Baines, like Adrian endangered Vardy, but I think neither meant any harm in any way and were both only going for the ball.
Spily milk now, though, so I'll stop crying.
|
Fifth Column
4:16 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
I prefer Adrian to Green as a 'fan' i.e. for his passion and entertainment levels... but Green is better than Adrian as a keeper in my eyes.
|
Rossal
4:08 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Green can do one
Thought he was better then the club and chased a pound note.
2 relegation's later and he wants to come back. Fcuk him.
If Randolph can't stand in for 3 games then why the bloody hell did we sign him ?
|
Gentile
4:05 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
If true i would be worried if i was Adrian.
Green is better than him.
|
Private Dancer
4:03 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
BB - It's looking like the Green0 story does has some legs, just waiting for QPR to get their new keeper over the line then they release Green to us.
|
Billy Blagg
3:59 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Not surprising and a correct decision IMHO. More worryingly is the fact we seem to have a No:2 that no-one trusts. That's really concerning.
|
Fifth Column
3:59 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Lily
In the written guidance issued to referees in relation to "serious foul play" it states that serious foul play involves "excessive force" and "endangers an opponent".
In my opinion based on my training as a ref, the Carlton one did not have enough force to meet that criteria but the Adrian one clearly did (for reasons I stated in my last post).
At the time on WHO I said I thought Carlton's red would get cancelled by the appeal panel which it did and I also said on here that the Adrian one would not be cancelled by the panel as it clearly did endanger the opponent.
I hope that helps.
|
Lily Hammer
3:44 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Fifth
Both were cases where a boots were raised, and studs hit the torso quite solidly; yes, Adrian's boot more solidly, but are you saying that the subtle differance you described (about the direction of the boots movement when it hits the torso) is actually mentioned in the rule-book?
I'd love a link to that rule if you can provide it. You're a ref, so you should be able to find that one.
|
Fifth Column
2:52 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Lily
Carlton's foot when it made contact was in a downward motion against the opponent's side.
Adrian's lunge had more force with his studs coming horizontally into the opponent's body.
That's the difference.
|
Fifth Column
2:51 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
103 people who don't know the rules ;-)
|
1964
1:39 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Lily Hammer 1:33 Wed Aug 19
... and the referee was..........
Unbelievable
|
Lily Hammer
1:33 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Have the rules changed since Carlton had his red (from the same ref v Everton) downgraded?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vy5mLiM76E
Exactly the same thing happened, but the panel let him off as his eyes were on the ball all the time.
Yellow for dangerous play, but not serious foul play or violent conduct, so shouldn't be red.
That's my opinion providing the rules haven't changed since Cole's incident.
|
1964
1:14 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
This wasn't a red and worse IMO
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-3200749/Former-Chelsea-striker-Demba-Ba-escapes-red-card-despite-horror-tackle-China.html?ito=video_player_click
|
mallard
1:14 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
I'm right behind Randolph on this one.
He's no mug, this will be his chance to nail down the no.1 spot, good luck to him!
|
Nigel Khazi
1:03 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Looks like Henri Lansbury will be moving from Forest soon, maybe we should sign him and put him between the sticks ;)
|
Ronald_antly
12:55 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Randolph will be OK once he gets match fit.
|
Fifth Column
12:34 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
You get an automatic 3 match ban for serious foul play. Nothing to do with our appeal.
|
mallard
12:17 Wed Aug 19
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
So does that mean he would have got less of a ban if we didn't appeal ?
|
cartis
11:58 Tue Aug 18
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
Exactly hairy this is a Fucking ridiculous situation we now find ourselves in.
Totally unprofessional.
|
HairyHammer
11:54 Tue Aug 18
Re: Adrian Red Card STANDS!!
|
This should have never been a problem every team in the prem must have two solid Goal keepers.
Why do we have one good one ok keeper ?
|
| 
